I credit our science editor, Tom Mansell, for putting me firmly in
a barleywine-craving mood with his What We Drank this week. 

The powerful,
intense style is gloriously complex and balanced when done right, and the
perfect answer to a long day or week as it reduces the world and all its
problems to the need for a nice cigar and bed.

Druid Fluid from Middle Ages  Brewing Company pours a light one-finger head and
orange-amber hue into a snifter glass, where it maintains light lacing. 

The
nose is vague orange flavors and a hint of cream puffs but mostly the understated
malt character of a relatively aged beer. 

There's no bottling date on this bottle
(ordinarily a red flag), but barleywines are traditionally crafted for
cellaring and Middle Ages specifically suggests aging this beer, so I
proceeded. 

On the palate there’s the sweet alcohol
typical of the style, some orange peel and a razor’s edge of harsh hops, but
that’s as far as it gets before a thin and resiny hop finish. 

At
traditional barleywine temperature (50-60 degrees F) it tastes tired; cooler
than that it gets  a boost from spotlighted carbonation but little
additional flavor. Though air time opened up just a bit more fruit esters, this
was ultimately more of a chore to drink than a contemplative indulgence.

The true barleywine ages with grace, losing
bright fresh notes but acquiring complexity, and without a bottling date to
give me any sense of the age of this beer I have to be concerned. This is
what’s on the shelves in my town, and it’s not indicative of the power and
beauty of the style. Brewers: date your bottles!

Producer: Middle Ages Brewing Company

ABV: 9.5%

Sample Size: 22 oz. bottle

Stemware: Snifter glass

Price: $6.50

Availability: Year-round

Grade: C+